
Turning a house key takes only a moment, but it asks a lot of the thumb. The thumb presses the key against the side of the index finger and holds it there while the hand turns. If an ache starts where the thumb meets the wrist, that small task can be more troublesome than carrying something heavier with both hands. Pain with pinching or twisting is common in thumb-base osteoarthritis, but it does not, by itself, tell you what is wrong. [1] [2] [3]
A useful starting point is to notice where the pain begins and which part of a task brings it on. Does it hurt to pick up the key, to hold it firmly, or only to turn a stiff lock? Does the thumb ache, catch, or go numb? Those distinctions can help a clinician examine the right area. They also give you a practical way to judge treatment: whether you can do something that matters to you more comfortably. [1] [3] [7]
What thumb-base arthritis can feel like
The thumb has more than one joint. The one called the carpometacarpal joint, or CMC joint, sits near the wrist, beneath the fleshy pad of the thumb. It is where the long thumb bone meets a small wrist bone called the trapezium. This joint lets the thumb swivel across the palm to meet the fingers. In osteoarthritis, the smooth cartilage covering the ends of the bones becomes thinner and rougher. The nearby knuckle and the joint closer to the thumbnail are different joints. [1] [2]
People often notice pain first during a pinch, when the thumb presses against a finger, or a grasp, when the fingers wrap around an object and the thumb steadies it. Pulling a zipper tab is a pinch. Holding a wide jar is a grasp. Opening that jar asks one hand to hold the glass while the other grips and turns the lid. It is worth noticing which hand hurts: the hand holding the jar still may be doing the harder part. [1] [2] [8]
The joint may ache after a long stretch of use, feel tender near the wrist, or seem too stiff to reach around a large cup. Some people notice swelling, a bony bump, weaker pinch, or aching at night. Symptoms can develop gradually and get worse over time. Some people manage for years with nonsurgical treatment. In fact, some people have substantial arthritis on an X-ray without troublesome pain. A visible bump or an imaging report is not, on its own, a reason to have treatment. [1] [2] [18]
When the pain might be coming from somewhere else
Several problems can make opening a jar or using scissors painful. These differences are useful to describe, not tests to perform at home:
- Pain along the thumb side of the wrist: In de Quervain’s, the tendons that move the thumb are painful where they pass through a narrow space at the wrist. Lifting the thumb or opening scissors can hurt. That location is close enough to the CMC joint that pointing to where the pain starts is more helpful than simply calling it thumb pain. [3] [22]
- A thumb that catches or locks: If the thumb sticks as you bend or straighten it, particularly with tenderness on the palm side, a clinician may consider trigger thumb. Here the tendon does not glide freely. A thumb that actually catches is a different complaint from a joint that moves smoothly but hurts under pressure. [3] [23]
- Numbness or pins and needles: Tingling that wakes you at night raises a different question from a deep ache with pinching. Carpal tunnel syndrome, a nerve problem at the wrist, is one possibility. It can occur alongside thumb-base arthritis, so an arthritis finding need not explain both sensations. [1] [3]
- Pain that began with an injury: A fall that bent the thumb away from the palm can injure a ligament at the knuckle and weaken pinch. A fracture can also cause pain and swelling. Describe the injury even if you already know you have arthritis; new pain should not automatically be attributed to the old finding. [3] [24]
- Several swollen joints and lingering morning stiffness: Tell your clinician if both hands are affected or if stiffness lasts well into the morning. Inflammatory conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis can affect several small joints and have different treatments. That pattern deserves consideration, but it does not establish a diagnosis either. [4]
When a thumb injury needs urgent care
After a thumb injury, go to the nearest emergency department if the thumb looks crooked or changes color, you lose feeling in part or all of the hand, you cannot move the thumb or hold objects, the pain is severe, you heard a snap, grinding, or popping sound at the time of injury, or the pain makes you feel faint, dizzy, or sick. Call 911 for a possible life-threatening emergency or if you need an ambulance. For swelling after a minor injury that is substantial or persists beyond a day or so, contact a clinician. [3] [25] [26]
Seek prompt medical care if the joint becomes hot, red, and swollen and you have a fever, or if pain, redness, or drainage increases after an injection or surgery. Follow your procedure team’s urgent-contact instructions. If you have symptoms of a medical emergency, go to the nearest emergency department right away. Call 911 for a possible life-threatening emergency. [16] [26] [27] [28]
What an evaluation can clarify
At Long Beach Lakewood Orthopedic Institute, we evaluate hand and wrist arthritis and other causes of hand symptoms. We ask about how the problem started and examine the hand and wrist. Our Hand & Wrist service describes the nonsurgical and surgical options we offer. If you are unsure where to start, our guide to choosing an orthopedic specialist explains how to describe the affected area and the task you are losing. You do not need to know the diagnosis to describe the problem. [5] [6]
The clinician may check which joint is tender, how the thumb moves, and whether moving it reproduces the pain you recognize. An X-ray can show narrowing between bones or extra bone around the joint. It cannot show how much it hurts to dress, cook, or finish a shift. If an X-ray shows arthritis but your main complaint is locking or numbness, a useful question is whether the image explains that particular symptom. [1] [3]
For the visit, choose one task you have changed and one you would like to get back. For example, you may still be able to write your name but have trouble filling out a full page, or you may be able to lift a mug but not turn a tight faucet. Bring a brace you already use and a list of medicines, including nonprescription gels. That gives the discussion somewhere specific to begin. [6] [7] [8] [14]
Making home and work tasks easier
The aim is not to stop using the hand. It is to find a way to do a valued task without asking a sore thumb to supply all the force. The British Society for Surgery of the Hand recommends starting with practical support: adapting activities and choosing suitable exercises. An occupational or hand therapist can help translate those ideas into changes that fit your day. [7] [8] [10]
| Everyday difficulty | A change to consider |
|---|---|
| A tight jar lid hurts to twist | Steady the jar on the counter and try a jar-opening aid that grips the lid. Notice whether the remaining difficulty is turning the lid or holding the jar steady. [8] |
| A narrow key is painful to pinch | A broad key turner gives the hand a larger surface to hold. If only one lock causes trouble, mention that detail before buying equipment for every key. [2] [8] |
| Writing or eating becomes uncomfortable | Try a wider pen barrel, a pen grip, or a utensil with a broader handle. The useful size is one you can control comfortably, not necessarily the largest one. [8] |
| Carrying a stack of papers hurts | Instead of pinching the stack at one edge, support it from underneath with both hands. The same idea can help when moving other light, awkward objects. [8] |
At work, describe the motion rather than relying on the job title. A desk job might involve opening binders or handling small clips for much of the day. In a trade, the difficult part may be holding a fitting still while the other hand turns a tool. Ask whether you can alternate tasks, change the grip, or break up a long stretch of pinching. If a change affects your control of equipment, discuss it with the person responsible for workplace safety rather than improvising on the job. [7] [8] [9]
Work can matter without explaining everything. A Swedish study of more than 237,000 male construction workers found that jobs involving heavier hand loads or repeated wrist movements were associated with more diagnoses of thumb-base arthritis. The researchers estimated exposures by occupation; they did not measure every worker’s individual tasks. The study cannot establish why one person developed arthritis. You can still ask for help with a painful task without first proving what caused the condition. [9]
Braces, exercise, and hand therapy
A thumb-base brace, also called a splint or orthosis, supports the sore joint. A softer support may leave more freedom for a task; a firmer one may steady the thumb but get in the way. Before choosing one, identify its job. Do you need support to write, to hold an object, or because the thumb aches at night? Ask someone to check the fit and show you when to wear it. A schedule that suits one person need not suit another. [1] [2] [7] [8]
The American College of Rheumatology’s 2026 guideline summary conditionally recommends braces for thumb-base arthritis. This leaves room to decide with your clinician whether a brace is likely to help with your particular activities. In a British trial of 349 adults, adding a thumb splint to a therapist-supported program did not improve average hand pain at eight weeks compared with the program alone. That is a reason to judge a brace by what it helps you do, not a reason to discard one that makes a difficult task easier. [10] [11]
Hand therapy can address movement, strength, and how you position the thumb during a pinch. It can also address something an exercise sheet misses: how to keep doing the activity that brought you in. If sewing is the goal, for example, show how you hold the fabric as well as the needle. Ask which movement an exercise is meant to improve and how to adjust it if it makes the thumb more painful. There is no need to copy someone else’s strengthening routine. [7] [8] [12]
Pain and function do not always change together. In an Australian trial of 204 adults, adding a splint, exercises, and diclofenac gel to education produced a modest improvement in hand function at six weeks, but no clear extra pain relief at that point. Both function and pain favored the combination at 12 weeks. The combination group also reported skin reactions and increased pain with exercise. In a Dutch trial of 166 adults, adding exercise therapy to a brace did not clearly improve three-month pain or reduce surgery within a year; some measures, including ability to work, favored the combined approach. Being able to finish a meal or a shift more comfortably is worth tracking alongside a pain score. [12] [13]
Pain relief: what to ask before using a gel, pill, or injection
For hand osteoarthritis, an anti-inflammatory gel such as diclofenac is one option. Ibuprofen and naproxen tablets belong to the same family of medicines, called NSAIDs. The 2026 guideline summary supports both topical and oral NSAIDs for hand arthritis and conditionally favors topical over oral treatment when appropriate. Oral NSAIDs can increase the risk of stomach bleeding and cardiovascular problems. The choice depends on your other medicines and health history. A gel may have fewer whole-body side effects than a tablet, but it is not risk-free. Gentle warmth or a cool pack is another comfort measure to discuss; do not put a heating pad over diclofenac gel. [1] [10] [14]
If you already take a pain reliever, check with a pharmacist or physician before adding an NSAID, even one that goes on the skin. Mention blood thinners, past ulcers or stomach bleeding, kidney or heart disease, pregnancy, and any reaction to aspirin or another NSAID. If you’re pregnant, ask before using an NSAID. The FDA advises avoiding NSAIDs at 20 weeks or later unless specifically directed by a healthcare professional. That warning does not replace instructions to take prescribed low-dose aspirin in pregnancy. [14] [29] Bring the labels if you are unsure what the products contain. For example, a tablet taken for knee pain still matters when you are choosing a gel for your thumb. Follow the product’s directions about when to stop and talk to a clinician. Call 911 for signs of serious bleeding, such as vomiting blood or passing black stools, or for chest pain, trouble breathing, or stroke symptoms. [14] [26]
A corticosteroid shot into the thumb-base joint is sometimes discussed when other measures have not made daily activities manageable. It may provide temporary relief, but the benefit is uncertain. British hand-surgery guidance considers it an option after less invasive care. The 2026 American College of Rheumatology summary conditionally recommends steroid injections for hand arthritis. The 2018 European rheumatology recommendations are more cautious about routine hand-joint steroid injections because thumb-base trials did not show a clear advantage over placebo. A shot is not a required step before discussing surgery. Ask what benefit would make it worthwhile for you. [7] [10] [15]
Steroid injections can cause a short flare of pain, carry a small infection risk, and temporarily raise blood sugar in people with diabetes. Ask about local skin thinning or lightening and the risk of tendon weakening before an injection. A different injection, platelet-rich plasma (PRP), should not be assumed to work better. In a trial of 90 people with thumb-base arthritis, a single PRP injection did not clearly outperform a saline injection for pain when using the thumb under load at six months. If offered an injection, ask what exactly is being injected, what evidence applies to the thumb, and what you would pay. [16] [17] [30]
Discussing surgery without committing to it
If pain still interferes with dressing, preparing food, paid work, or another activity you value, a surgical consultation can help you compare options. Continuing without surgery is also a choice. In one long-term study, 22% of the 217 people who responded to follow-up had gone on to surgery after starting nonsurgical care, at a typical follow-up of seven years. That is not a prediction for an individual, but it illustrates that starting with a brace and therapy does not put everyone on a countdown to an operation. [7] [18]
One common operation, trapeziectomy, removes the small wrist bone at the base of the thumb. Some versions use a tendon to support the thumb or fill the space. Fusion instead joins the bones so that the painful joint no longer moves; that trades movement for stability. The term CMC arthroplasty can refer to different ways of reconstructing the thumb-base joint. Ask which operation your surgeon is discussing and what would be removed, supported, or replaced. [1] [21]
We offer evaluation and treatment for thumb arthritis through our Hand & Wrist service. This guide is published by the practice that offers that care. [5]
An extra surgical step does not necessarily mean a better result. A randomized study that followed 153 operated thumbs for at least five years found similar pain relief and pinch strength after trapeziectomy alone and two versions that added tendon procedures. A 2026 Cochrane review likewise found low-certainty evidence of little or no difference in pain or function from adding ligament reconstruction and tendon tissue rather than removing the bone alone. These comparisons do not tell you whether surgery is better for you than continuing nonsurgical care. [19] [20]
Before choosing, talk through an ordinary day after the procedure. Buttoning clothes, driving, caring for another person, and operating a tool make different demands on the hand. Recovery can take months and may involve a splint or cast and hand therapy. Risks vary by procedure and can include infection, nerve irritation, and persistent pain. Ask about the trade-offs of the exact procedure proposed. Ask for a distinction between returning to some work and returning to your usual grip and lifting duties. That difference may matter more to your decision than the date of the operation. [1] [21]
Questions to ask your physician or care team
- Can you show me which joint or tendon you think is painful? Does that also explain the catching or numbness I notice?
- Would an X-ray change what we do, and which findings match my examination?
- Can I show you how I hold my key, pen, or work tool so we can try a different grip?
- What should a brace help me do? How will I know whether the fit or wearing schedule needs to change?
- Which pain-relief options fit my medication list and health history? What would make an injection worth considering?
- If I continue without surgery, what changes in pain or function should we use to revisit the decision?
- If we discuss an operation, what would it change about my pinch strength and motion? What help or modified duties might I need while I recover?
Learn More
- American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS), OrthoInfo. Arthritis of the Thumb.
- British Society for Surgery of the Hand (BSSH). Basal thumb arthritis.
- NHS. Thumb pain. Common causes and symptom patterns; reviewed June 6, 2025.
- American College of Rheumatology (ACR). Rheumatoid Arthritis. Patient guidance.
- Long Beach Lakewood Orthopedic Institute. Hand & Wrist.
- Long Beach Lakewood Orthopedic Institute. How to Choose the Right Orthopedic Specialist for Your Symptoms.
- Gangopadhyay S, et al. BSSH BEST guideline on managing thumb-base osteoarthritis. Journal of Hand Surgery, European Volume. 2025. PMID 39852312. Published recommendations and society evidence report.
- South Tees Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. Osteoarthritis of the carpometacarpal thumb joint. Hand-therapy guidance and examples of adapted tasks.
- Lewis C, et al. Occupational risk factors for thumb CMC osteoarthritis in construction workers. Occupational and Environmental Medicine. 2025. DOI 10.1136/oemed-2024-109949.
- American College of Rheumatology. 2026 Osteoarthritis Guideline Summary. Posted September 14, 2026; hand and first-CMC recommendations.
- Adams J, et al. Randomized trial of splints for thumb-base osteoarthritis. Rheumatology. 2021. PMID 33254239; DOI 10.1093/rheumatology/keaa726.
- Deveza LA, et al. Combination conservative treatment versus education for thumb-base osteoarthritis: the COMBO randomized trial. JAMA Internal Medicine. 2021. DOI 10.1001/jamainternmed.2020.7101.
- Wouters RM, et al. Exercise therapy plus an orthosis versus an orthosis alone for thumb CMC osteoarthritis. Osteoarthritis and Cartilage. Online 2025; May 2026 issue. PMID 41138847; DOI 10.1016/j.joca.2025.10.005.
- DailyMed, U.S. National Library of Medicine. Diclofenac sodium topical gel, 1%: OTC Drug Facts. Indications, interactions, pregnancy warning, and directions.
- Kloppenburg M, et al. EULAR recommendations for management of hand osteoarthritis, 2018 update. Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases. 2019;78:16–24. DOI 10.1136/annrheumdis-2018-213826.
- AAOS, OrthoInfo. Cortisone Shot (Steroid Injection). General injection risks.
- Evans K, et al. Platelet-Rich Plasma Injection for Painful Trapeziometacarpal Osteoarthritis. Placebo-controlled randomized trial. JBJS Open Access. 2025. DOI 10.2106/JBJS.OA.25.00027.
- Esteban Lopez LMJ, et al. Long-term outcomes of nonsurgical treatment of thumb CMC osteoarthritis: a cohort study. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, American Volume. 2023. PMID 37903291; DOI 10.2106/JBJS.22.01116.
- Gangopadhyay S, et al. Five- to 18-year follow-up comparing three variations of trapeziectomy. Journal of Hand Surgery, American Volume. 2012;37:411–417. PMID 22305824.
- Baljer B, Vinycomb T, Low N. Surgery for thumb (trapeziometacarpal joint) osteoarthritis. Cochrane review update, May 28, 2026. DOI 10.1002/14651858.CD004631.pub6.
- AAOS, OrthoInfo. Thumb Carpometacarpal (CMC) Arthroplasty. Procedure, risks, recovery, and work considerations.
- BSSH. De Quervain’s syndrome.
- AAOS, OrthoInfo. Trigger Finger (including trigger thumb).
- AAOS, OrthoInfo. Sprained Thumb.
- MedlinePlus. Finger pain.
- MedlinePlus. When to use the emergency room.
- MedlinePlus. Septic arthritis.
- MedlinePlus. Surgical wound infection.
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Avoid NSAIDs at 20 weeks of pregnancy or later unless advised by a healthcare professional.
- Mayo Clinic. Cortisone shots: risks and what to expect.
